January 2007
 
 

Commercial Breakdowns: The 10 Greatest Films About Advertising
By Robert Cherry

We are vain, shallow mercenaries stressed to the brink of nervous exhaustion and yet we think everyone else is beneath us—especially curmudgeonly clients and lemming-like consumers.

If you were to base your perceptions solely on Hollywood movies, that is the image you would have of us, the men and women working in the field of advertising. As with most Hollywood portrayals, the image, of course, is way off base—in no way are we vain.

But if the unflattering stereotypes don’t apply, perhaps we can find at least some useful fact among the fiction. Here, we revisit the most entertaining portrayals of our industry and, between laughs, search for a practical lesson in each film—something we might actually apply in our day jobs… before they cart us off for a long, long rest.

10. Lost in America (1985)

Plot: Yuppie ad exec David Howard (Albert Brooks) and his wife Linda (Julia Hagerty) quit their high-paying jobs to drop out of society a la the antiheroes in “Easy Rider.” Cue montage of the couple cruising down the highway in a Winnebago to the sound of Steppenwolf’s “Born To Be Wild.” Unfortunately, one of their first stops is Las Vegas, where Linda loses their financial nest egg at the roulette table (“Say it! Say it! Say, ‘I lost the nest egg!’”). The sudden downturn forces the couple to take minimum-wage jobs (“We’re in hell. We’ve entered hell!”).

Classic Quote: “As the boldest experiment in advertising history, you give us our money back,” says David, pleading with the Desert Inn’s casino manager.

Lesson: Feeding your soul outside of work brings renewed enthusiasm for the job. Or as a small-town employment agent tells David, “You couldn’t change your life on a hundred-thousand
a year?”

 

9. What Women Want (2000)

Plot: Following a freak accident involving a hair dryer and a bathtub, chauvinist art director Nick Marshall (Mel Gibson) discovers he can hear women’s thoughts. He uses his newfound ability to get in touch with the female demographic (“and those cuckoo things they do”) and, ultimately, his boss Darcy McGuire (Helen Hunt)—but only after he experiences the pain of female primping first-hand.

Classic Quote: “I'm the man-eating bitch Darth Vader of the ad world,” says Darcy.

Lesson: Know your target audience, even if it means walking a mile in their high-heeled shoes after waxing your delicate regions (“…in one smooth motion, pull strip in the opposite direction of
the growth…. ”)

 

8. Advertising Rules! (2001)

Plot: In this quirky romantic comedy from German director Lars Kraume, geeky, young Viktor Vogel (Alexander Scheer) bluffs his way into an ad meeting, charms the client with an irreverent remark, and finds himself hired to concept a car campaign. Seizing the moment, he dresses for his new role in a camouflage-print suit and becomes the agency’s hot creative director—but only after borrowing an idea from his arty girlfriend. His scheme, of course, then begins to unravel.

Classic Quote: “Vogel? Viktor Vogel? Even the name sucks,” says Vogel’s new boss and would-be partner.

Lesson: Faking it ‘til you make it only works if you have the talent to back it up—and haven’t forged your resume… or stolen your ideas.

 

7. How To Get Ahead in Advertising (1989)

Plot: Under pressure to create a slogan for pimple cream, ad guy Denis Dimbleby Bagley (Richard E. Grant) suffers a nervous breakdown. His crisis of faith is manifested as a stress-induced boil on his shoulder, which ultimately grows into a second head with the conscience of a Marxist. Arguments with the boil ensue, with Bagley concluding that “the world is one magnificent shop, and if it hasn't got a price tag, it isn't worth having.”

Classic Quote: “[Consumers] are entitled to any innovation technology brings, whether it's 10 percent more of it or 15 percent off of it,” Bagley declares. “They're entitled to one of four important new ingredients. Why should anyone have to clean their teeth without important new ingredients?”

Lesson: Always abide by a solid code of ethics. Barring that, have a good therapist on hand. And/or a dermatologist.

 

6. Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House (1948)

Plot: Ad exec Jim Blandings (Cary Grant), under duress from his social-climbing wife, Muriel (Irene Dunne), decides to build his dream home in the suburbs. The ensuing problems with the contractors (“So, you hit a spring, a bubbling spring... right here, in our cellar…”) and grief from his wife (“I refuse to endanger the lives of my children in a house with less than four bathrooms!”) leave Blandings with creative block.

Classic Quote: Blandings’s maid, Gussie, inadvertently comes up with the winning ad slogan, declaring: “If you ain't eatin' Wham, you ain't eatin' ham!”

Lesson: Bringing your work home can yield better results than bringing your home life to work. But ultimately, neither is recommended.

 

5. I'll Never Forget What's 'Isname (1967)

Plot: This out-there British classic opens with Andrew Quint (Oliver Reed) sauntering into his agency with an axe slung over his shoulder and chopping his office furniture into kindling while his shocked colleagues look on. When he tells his boss, Jonathan Lute (played with camp reserve by Orson Welles), that he’s going to find an honest job, Lute responds, “Silly boy, there aren’t any.” It only gets stranger—and darker—from there, including a great dream sequence in the form of a period camera commercial.

Classic Quote: “Our nation gets the advertising it deserves,” says Lute. “It’s all a lot of pretentious rubbish.”

Lesson: Install an air hockey, ping-pong or foosball table in your place of employment so colleagues can work out their tensions in a civilized fashion. Oh, and a metal detector….

 

4. The Hucksters (1947)

Plot: Just out of the service, Victor Albee Norman (Clark Gable) lands a job at an ad firm, complete with the archetypal Client From Hell, Beautee Soap baron Evan Llewellyn Evans (Sydney Greenstreet). In an archetypal Meeting From Hell, Evans bullies Norman to use an inappropriate print ad that he and his staff of yes-men have created.

Classic Quote: Evans clears his throat, spits on the conference table, and says, “Mr. Norman, you’ve just seen me do a disgusting thing. But you’ll always remember what I just did. You see, Mr. Norman, if nobody remembers your brand you aren’t going to sell any soap!”

Lesson: Don’t let the promise of short-term results degrade your brand’s long-term equity. As Norman tells the soap baron, “Beautee Soap is a clean product, and your advertisement is not clean!”

 

3. Plains, Trains And Automobiles (1987)

Plot: Nothing quite captures the jet-setting glamour of the job like this John Hughes classic. When a client deliberates over a campaign, Neil Page (Steve Martin) misses his flight home for Thanksgiving and ends up with shower-ring salesman Del Griffith (John Candy) as his traveling companion. Neil eventually makes it home… three days, two pillows (“Those aren’t pillows!”), and one incinerated rental car later (“We had a small fire last night, officer, but we caught it in the nick of time”).

Classic Quote: Too many to list, really, but here’s a favorite… “Have mercy,” Neil says, pleading with a hotel clerk. “I've been wearing the same underwear since Tuesday.”

“I can vouch for that,” says Del.

Lesson: When traveling, follow Del’s lead—just go with the flow “like the twigs in a mighty long stream.” And, please, pack any carry-on toiletries—only 3 oz. per container—in a quart-size Ziploc bag et cetera.

 

2. Putney Swope (1969)

Plot: This edgy satire of white corporate America and the then-burgeoning counter-culture still raises eyebrows as well as laughs almost 40 years after its release. When an African-American ad exec accidentally gains control of a flagging agency, he promises he won’t rock the boat… he’ll sink it. He subsequently replaces the otherwise all-white staff with his militant friends—whom he then fires one by one, only after they’ve come up with arty ad concepts he can claim as his own.

Classic Quote: Putney spells out the ground rules for clients clamoring to do business with the hot agency of the moment. “Give us the name of your product, what it’s supposed to do, then take a walk. We don’t need your ideas. We don’t need your advice. And we don’t need lames in the hallway.”

Lesson: Disrupting the staid agency model can produce great results, but professional courtesy and the spirit of collaboration still have a place.

 

1. Crazy People (1990)

Plot: Ad exec Emory Leeson (Dudley Moore) suffers, yep, a melt-down and finds himself in the nut house. His career begins to flourish, however, with the help of his fellow patients and a new strategy—brutally honest advertising. Slogans generated with the new approach include: “This movie won't just scare you, it will [expletive deleted] you up for life" and “You may think phone service stinks since deregulation, but don't mess with us, because we're all you've got.”

Classic Quote: “We can't level, you crazy bastard, we're in advertising!” says Emory’s boss, Stephen Bachman (Paul Reiser).

Lesson: The so-called professionals may not have the best answers. Always listen to the consumer and keep your eyes and ears open for fresh ideas—no matter how nutty they may at first appear.

 


Robert Cherry is Senior Writer at Seed Strategy. As a freelance journalist he has contributed to “Rolling Stone,” “Guitar One” and Cleveland’s “The Plain Dealer.” Contact him at rcherry@seedstrategy.com.

Commercial Breakdowns: The 10 Greatest Films About Advertising
 


Introducing The New And Improved Evil Scumbug
It’s a rich irony that ad people—those who help shape perception—have such a dubious public image, often ranking alongside lawyers in opinion polls rating least-trustworthy professions.


Marketing insights from the frontlines.


A few words from the wise.

 

 

 

 

 
 
   
© 2006 Seed Strategy Inc.